This is a guest post by Darren Rippy. Darren is a graduate student in the Master of Public Policy program at the College of William & Mary. He is a summer policy fellow at the Virginia Interfaith Center for Public Policy.
Arizona’s controversial immigration law has garnered intense scrutiny — and refocused our attention around the issue of immigration reform and illegal immigrants.
Public discourse concerning the law has been fiery and politically divisive. Critics have labeled it as racist, xenophobic, and possibly unconstitutional. As usual, the media has depicted the issue as a strictly red-blue, left-right divide. The result has been the usual conjuring up of loaded images concerning immigration, which is mainly that undocumented persons are here to do America harm and must be kept out.
During an interview on WTOP, Gov. Bob McDonnell voiced skepticism concerning particular aspects of the Arizona law:
I’m concerned about the whole idea of carrying papers and always having to be able to prove your citizenship. That brings up some shades of some other regimes that weren’t necessarily helpful to democracy.
Prominent faith leaders have called into question the morality of Arizona’s new law, and the enforcement-only strategy in general. Cardinal Joseph Mahony, the Roman Catholic Archbishop of Los Angeles, asserts,
The tragedy of the law [Arizona’s new law] is its totally flawed reasoning: that immigrants come to our country to rob, plunder, and consume public resources. That is not only false, the premise is nonsense.
Jim Wallis, President and CEO of Sojourners, has called the Arizona law a social and racial sin. He explains in a recent blog post,
We all want to live in a nation of laws, and the immigration system in the U.S. is so broken that it is serving no one well. But enforcement without reform of the system is merely cruel. Enforcement without compassion is immoral. Enforcement that breaks up families is unacceptable. And enforcement of this law would force us to violate our Christian conscience, which we simply will not do. It makes it illegal to love your neighbor in Arizona.
Read more…